|
| 由形式证成到实质证立:正当程序原则对博士学位论文盲审制度的适用与优化 |
| From Formal Compliance to Substantive Justification: Applying the Due Process Principle to Optimize the Doctoral Dissertation Blind Review System |
| 投稿时间:2025-09-12 |
| DOI:10.19834/j.cnki.yjsjy2011.2026.04.03 |
| 中文关键词: 博士学位论文;匿名评阅;正当程序;学术权力;学生权利 |
| 英文关键词: doctoral dissertation;double-blind review;due process;academic power;student rights |
| 基金项目:国家自然科学基金重点项目“面向国家重大需求的研究生教育治理体系研究”(72134001) |
| 作者 | 单位 | | 孙莉 | 北京航空航天大学 公共管理学院, 北京 100191 | | 赵世奎 | 北京航空航天大学 公共管理学院, 北京 100191 | | 都仁 | 北京航空航天大学 公共管理学院, 北京 100191 | | 吴彬 | 北京教育科学研究院 高等教育科学研究所, 北京 100036 |
|
| 摘要点击次数: 368 |
| 全文下载次数: 238 |
| 中文摘要: |
| 博士学位论文盲审制度是博士学位授予质量保障的核心环节,然其制度定位的特殊性与结果的高风险性,使其面临合法性基础松动与合理性共识弱化的挑战。博士学位论文盲审所行使的权力并非纯粹的学术权力,而是源于国家授权、兼具行政确认与学术判断属性的复合性权力。鉴于该权力的行使直接关涉公民受教育权的实现,须接受正当程序原则的约束。通过厘清正当程序原则适用于博士论文盲审的法理基石与边界,本文主张规制的关键在于聚焦权力行使的程序正当性本身,而非干预学术判断的实质内容。基于此,构建分阶递进的程序保障框架,并通过对高校现行博士学位论文盲审政策的系统分析,揭示其在决策参与、专家遴选、结果认定及救济渠道等环节存在的程序瑕疵。未来博士学位论文盲审制度应在“输入端”贯彻“参与型”正当程序,促进制度公开公正;在“过程端”嵌入“有限型”正当程序,保障评审过程的中立严谨;在“输出端”强化“严格型”正当程序,兼顾质量管理与权益保障,超越形式合规,实现实质正当,达致程序正义与实体正义的有机统一。 |
| 英文摘要: |
| The blind review system for doctoral dissertations serves as a key mechanism for ensuring the quality of doctoral degree conferral. However, its unique institutional characteristics and high-stakes nature have recently called its legitimacy into question and undermined consensus on its underlying rationale.The authority exercised in blind reviews is not purely academic but rather a composite power delegated by the state, combining elements of administrative confirmation and academic judgment. Given that this authority bears directly on the realization of citizens’ right to education, it must be subject to the principle of due process. By clarifying the legal foundations and boundaries of applying the due process principle to doctoral dissertation blind reviews,this paper contends that the key to regulating this authority lies in focusing on the procedural legitimacy of its exercise, rather than intervening in the substantive content of academic judgment.On this basis, the paper constructs a phased, progressive procedural safeguard framework and, through a systematic analysis of current university doctoral blind review policies, reveals procedural flaws in key areas including participation in decision-making, reviewer selection, outcome determination, and appeal mechanisms. The paper thus advocates that future doctoral blind review systems should implement “participatory” due process at the “input stage” to promote institutional transparency and fairness; embed “limited” due process at the “process stage” to ensure neutrality and rigor in the review; and strengthen “stringent” due process at the “output stage” to balance quality management with rights protection. By transcending formal compliance and achieving substantive due process, the system should realize the organic unity of procedural justice and substantive justice. |
|
查看HTML全文
查看全文
查看/发表评论 下载PDF阅读器 |
| 关闭 |